Scalable Capital vs Trade Republic: Comparison for German Investors

With offerings like Scalable Capital and Trade Republic each promising unique benefits, the question is: which one is really the best for you? 🤔 In this comprehensive guide, we'll go over the crucial factors that will influence your choice.

Key Takeaways

  • No one-size-fits-all broker. Personal circumstances dictate the best choice. Perspective matters in financial decisions.
  • Analyze factors: costs, fees, securities, accounts. Tailor your choice to your investment strategy and goals.
  • Scalable Capital and Trade Republic offer free accounts, but premium plans offer minor perks.
  • Order fees vary slightly. Rather focus on strategies with more impact than small fee differences.
  • As tradable securities, both offer stocks, ETFs, and derivatives. Trade Republic stands out with actual cryptocurrencies.
  • High-yield savings accounts at both, but rates can change. Explore diverse financial instruments beyond brokers.
  • Scalable Capital and Trade Republic offer tax-free profit limits. Consider broader tax-saving strategies.
  • Scalable Capital’s kids’ account vs. versatility of other brokers. Seek cost-effective options for children’s investments.
  • ING offers “Kleingeldsparen” function with automatic investments. Focus on effective financial strategies.
  • Prioritize a holistic financial approach. The big picture matters – income, expenses, and tax efficiency drive success.

Introduction: Which Broker In Germany Is The Best (For You)?

Are you ready to embark on your investment journey in Germany but unsure about the ideal broker to choose? It’s a question that has likely crossed your mind as you navigate the sea of options available.

Should you opt for a local broker like Scalable Capital or Trade Republic, or consider international giants like Interactive Brokers or Degiro? Well, we’re here to guide you through this decision-making process. In this Perfinex investing blog post, we’ll discuss the intricacies of these German brokers to help you make an informed choice.

Determining the best broker in Germany is a personalized journey that hinges on your distinct financial circumstances, objectives, and preferences. While claims of a universally superior broker might abound, it’s vital to recognize that individual financial situations are far from uniform.

Each investor’s needs and goals differ, rendering a singular solution impractical. Therefore, embarking on a comprehensive broker comparison requires a keen awareness of your unique financial landscape and aspirations. Let’s establish a foundation for this thorough evaluation.

Most Important Details To Compare German Brokers

Selecting the appropriate broker entails a comprehensive evaluation of numerous critical factors. Among these considerations are account costs, order fees, the range of tradable securities, options for savings accounts, tax-free profit thresholds, and the availability of kids’ investment accounts.

However, the significance of each of these factors varies depending on your individual investment strategy and financial objectives. Your chosen broker must align with your specific preferences and long-term goals. By delving into these essential details, you can make a more informed decision about which German broker suits your unique needs.

Account Costs Of Scalable Capital & Trade Republic

When assessing the account costs of Scalable Capital and Trade Republic, it’s evident that both brokers provide free accounts to users who establish and maintain them without activity. Nevertheless, Scalable Capital introduces two premium plans – Prime Broker and Prime Plus Broker – at a monthly cost of €2.99 and €4.99, respectively. These plans boast zero order fees, which may appear enticing at first glance.

However, it’s essential to critically evaluate whether this marginal cost saving indeed translates into a significant advantage for your investment strategy. Rather than fixating solely on small differences in account fees, it’s prudent to consider the broader context of your financial goals and preferred investment approach. While costs undoubtedly play a role, they should be weighed against other substantial factors in the broker selection process.

If you wanna avoid taxes when investing in Germany, feel free to schedule a free meeting with us. We will help you finding the best solution for you.

Order Fees Of Scalable Capital & Trade Republic

Diving into the realm of order fees, Scalable Capital and Trade Republic exhibit differing fee structures. Scalable Capital imposes a modest charge of 99 cents per order, while Trade Republic stands out with a flat one-euro order fee.

Although on the surface this might seem like a minuscule cost variation, it’s crucial to take a step back and evaluate the broader implications within the context of your financial strategy. Making investment decisions solely based on marginal differences in order fees might divert attention from the more substantial components that truly impact your returns and overall financial picture.

Before fixating on these nominal fee distinctions, it’s prudent to assess your investment frequency, the size of your investments, and your overall trading habits. Ultimately, the key is to align your broker choice with your larger financial goals and trading behavior, making order fees just one piece of the puzzle.

Tradable Securities On Scalable Capital & Trade Republic

The investment landscape offered by both Scalable Capital and Trade Republic encompasses a wide array of options, including stocks, exchange-traded funds (ETFs), and derivatives. This breadth of choice underscores their commitment to addressing the diverse investment needs of their users. While their offerings are robust and well-aligned with the financial aspirations of most investors, it’s noteworthy that both platforms cater to the mainstream investment preferences that make up the bulk of the market.

However, if cryptocurrencies are a realm you’re venturing into or considering, Trade Republic takes a lead over Scalable Capital (August 2023). Trade Republic distinguishes itself by providing access to real cryptocurrencies, offering an avenue to invest in the rapidly growing and evolving world of digital currencies. This is an important differentiation to consider if you’re looking to diversify your investment portfolio beyond traditional asset classes.

When evaluating the tradable securities offered by these platforms, it’s essential to keep your investment goals, risk tolerance, and portfolio diversification strategies in mind. Scalable Capital and Trade Republic may share commonalities in the variety of assets they offer, but your investment choices should ultimately be guided by your individual financial aspirations and preferences.

Savings Accounts Of Scalable Capital & Trade Republic

For those seeking a high-yield savings account to complement their investment strategy, both Scalable Capital and Trade Republic present viable options. Scalable Capital’s Prime Plus Broker introduces an enticing 2.6% interest rate (August 2023), while Trade Republic’s savings account offers a competitive 2% interest rate (August 2023). These rates, however, are subject to market fluctuations and adjustments over time, so it’s wise to approach them with a long-term perspective.

It’s crucial to recognize that the availability of savings accounts with competitive interest rates is just one aspect of a comprehensive financial approach. While it’s advantageous to consider the additional perks and features that brokers offer, it’s equally essential to widen your perspective. This extends to exploring diverse financial instruments that can augment your financial growth and stability.

Rather than viewing broker offerings in isolation, it’s valuable to see them as part of a larger financial ecosystem. Engaging with a mix of investment vehicles, savings options, and financial strategies will empower you to make informed decisions that align with your financial goals. So, while evaluating the savings account offerings of Scalable Capital and Trade Republic is insightful, it’s just one step in a broader journey of building financial resilience and success.

Tax-Free Profits Of Scalable Capital & Trade Republic

Navigating the intricacies of taxation is a paramount consideration in the realm of German investments. Both Scalable Capital and Trade Republic extend an annual tax-free profit allowance of €1,000, providing investors with a buffer against taxation on their gains. However, it’s important to recognize that tax optimization doesn’t solely hinge on broker terms.

For those in marital partnerships, exploring the offerings of other brokers could reveal more advantageous terms for tax-free profits. Many other brokers in Germany provide joint accounts that can yield higher tax-free profit limits, accommodating both spouses’ individual allowances. Therefore, widening your scope to consider alternative brokerage options can have a meaningful impact on your overall tax efficiency.

While broker features play a significant role in shaping your investment strategy, they are just one piece of the larger puzzle. By combining insights from various brokerage offerings with an understanding of tax regulations, you can devise a comprehensive strategy that optimizes tax-free profits and overall financial growth. Ultimately, staying well-informed about tax-related benefits across the spectrum of investment options empowers you to make well-rounded decisions that align with your financial aspirations.

Kids Accounts Of Scalable Capital & Trade Republic

Parents aiming to secure their children’s financial future often explore investment options tailored for the younger generation. Scalable Capital presents a kids’ account within its Robo advisor platform, offering an opportunity to start building an investment portfolio for your children. In contrast, Trade Republic does not offer a specific kids’ account option as part of its brokerage services (August 2023).

While Scalable Capital’s kids’ account caters to a certain demographic, it’s essential to recognize that your preferences and goals may lead you to alternative solutions. If you’re seeking a more versatile approach that allows greater control over investment choices and lower costs, exploring brokers beyond Scalable Capital and Trade Republic could be prudent.

Several German brokers offer kids’ accounts with specialized features and reduced fees. These accounts often grant parents the flexibility to choose from a broader range of investment options while benefiting from favorable cost structures. Considering these alternative options ensures that your child’s investment journey aligns with your family’s financial objectives.

Our Conclusion Of The German Broker Battle

In the grand arena of the German broker battle, our recommendation carries a profound lesson: prioritize the financial elements that hold real significance in your life. While we’ve meticulously dissected the nuances of Scalable Capital and Trade Republic, it’s imperative to recognize that slight fee differentials are dwarfed by the potential gains stemming from strategic and informed investments.

In the pursuit of financial prosperity, allocating energy and time to optimize insignificant fee variations can lead to missed opportunities in more impactful domains. Instead of fixating on nominal costs, consider channeling your efforts into comprehending investment strategies, tax-saving avenues, and wealth-building methods. The choice to look beyond the realm of marginal fee differences reinforces the idea that focusing on the broader financial landscape reaps more substantial rewards.

As you navigate the diverse options offered by German brokers, remember that every financial decision is an integral part of your comprehensive strategy. Distinguishing between the trivial and the transformative can reshape your investment journey, ensuring that your efforts align with the overarching goal of achieving financial well-being. In the end, this approach echoes a resounding call to direct your attention towards the significant aspects that have the potential to shape your financial future.

Why We Chose ING As Personal Broker

Our decision to opt for ING as a personal broker transcends the realm of trifling order fees. Instead, it finds its foundation in a groundbreaking and visionary feature known as “Kleingledsparen.” This innovative mechanism possesses the power to transform small, everyday purchases into significant investments. Operating on a simple principle, Kleingeldsparen rounds up each transaction to the nearest Euro or even five Euros, channeling these nominal differences directly into investment opportunities.

The true genius of this approach lies in its sophistication: The rounded-up amounts add up over time and result in a tangible impact on your financial well-being. By moving away from fixating on tiny differences in fees and looking at the big picture, you harness the power of incremental change to deliver significant growth to your investment portfolio.

In the ever-evolving landscape of brokerage offerings, the decision to join ING underscores the value of forward-looking innovation that goes beyond superficial costs. This decision exemplifies the philosophy that small, intentional actions over time can deliver transformative results. In essence, the decision to go with ING underscores the general principle that wealth creation is not about watching every penny, but rather about taking advantage of innovative opportunities to have a profound impact on one’s financial trajectory.

If you need help with investments in Germany, make a free appointment with us. We will help you find the best solution for you.


In conclusion, the battle between Scalable Capital and Trade Republic for the title of the “best” German broker illuminates a crucial principle: the importance of perspective in making financial decisions. While comparisons of account costs, order fees, tradable securities, and other details are valuable, they often overshadow the broader strategies that truly impact your financial journey.

Your choice of a broker should be viewed as part of a holistic approach to wealth management. Rather than getting lost in minute fee discrepancies, prioritize the substantial gains attainable through well-considered investments and strategic financial planning. Remember that true financial success is forged by focusing on the big picture – increasing your income, optimizing your expenses, and capitalizing on tax-efficient avenues.

The decision to choose ING as a broker underscores this philosophy. Instead of getting bogged down in low order fees, harness the power of innovative features like “Kleingeldsparen” to make significant financial progress.

Ultimately, the best broker for you hinges on aligning your choice with your unique financial goals, circumstances, and preferences. By adopting a mindset that values long-term strategies over minor nuances, you position yourself for enduring financial prosperity. So, while the Scalable Capital vs. Trade Republic comparison is important, it’s the broader financial principles that truly hold the key to your success.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.